The Church Revitalization Podcast – Episode 254

As church leaders, we often pour our hearts and souls into crafting meaningful Sunday worship services. But how do we know if we’re truly hitting the mark? It’s easy to become blind to issues that may be glaringly obvious to newcomers or even long-time attendees. That’s why regular evaluation of our services is crucial. Let’s look at three questions to help you take a fresh look at what you do.

Question 1: Are We Consistent?

Consistency is a cornerstone of building trust and meeting expectations. Think about it: you can walk into any McDonald’s around the world and have a pretty good idea of what to expect. While we’re not comparing our churches to fast-food chains, there’s a valuable lesson here about the power of predictability.

When people come to your church, particularly those who attend regularly, do they know what to expect? This doesn’t mean your service needs to follow the exact same formula every week, but there should be a level of consistency that provides comfort and familiarity.

Consider these aspects of consistency:

1. Service Structure: Is there a recognizable flow to your service from week to week?
2. Music Style: Does your worship style remain relatively consistent, or does it vary wildly from Sunday to Sunday?
3. Preaching: If you have a rotation of speakers, is there a consistent quality and style across all messages?

However, be cautious of being consistently bad. If certain elements of your service consistently underperform or receive negative feedback, it’s time to address those issues rather than maintain them for the sake of consistency.

Balancing consistency with variety can be tricky, but it’s essential for creating a worship experience that is both comforting and engaging. Small, intentional variations within a consistent framework can keep your services fresh without alienating your congregation.

An even greater danger is allowing tradition to rise to an unhealthy level. Tradition in keeping important, biblical elements in front of people is healthy. Rigidity regardless of effectiveness is not.

Remember, every Sunday could be someone’s first Sunday at your church. A consistent, welcoming experience can make all the difference in whether they decide to return.

Question 2: Are We Continuously Improving?

While consistency is crucial, it shouldn’t come at the expense of growth and improvement. The church, like any organization, should be in a constant state of refinement and development. This doesn’t mean changing for the sake of change, but rather thoughtfully innovating to better serve your congregation and community.

Here are some strategies for continuous improvement:

1. Weekly Debriefs: After each service, gather your team for a quick discussion. What worked well? What could have been better? These regular check-ins can catch small issues before they become big problems.
2. Seek Feedback: Regularly ask your congregation for their thoughts. This could be through surveys, suggestion boxes, or informal conversations. Remember, your members often see things from a perspective you might miss.
3. Stay Culturally Relevant: While the message of the Gospel never changes, the methods we use to communicate it can and should adapt to reach people effectively. Regularly evaluate whether your approach resonates with your current and target audience.
4. Invest in Training: Continuous improvement isn’t just about changing processes; it’s about developing people. Invest in training for your staff and volunteers to enhance their skills and knowledge.
5. Look for Problems Proactively: As a leader, train yourself to look for areas of improvement. It’s better to identify and address issues on your own terms rather than waiting for them to escalate into major problems.

However, it’s important to balance improvement with maintaining your core values and identity. Not every new idea is a good idea, and not every problem needs an innovative solution. Sometimes, the best improvement is a return to basics or a recommitment to your foundational principles.

For smaller churches or those with limited staff, this process might look different. If you’re a bivocational pastor or the sole staff member, consider partnering with a trusted elder, board member, or volunteer leader for these evaluations. Having a sounding board can be invaluable in processing thoughts and identifying areas for growth.

Remember, the goal of continuous improvement isn’t perfection, but rather a commitment to becoming more effective in your mission week after week. It’s about creating a culture where growth and learning are valued, and where everyone is invested in making your worship services the best they can be.

Question 3: Are We Excited? 

The final question might be the most crucial: Are we excited about our church and our services? This isn’t about manufacturing a false sense of enthusiasm, but rather cultivating a genuine, contagious excitement that permeates every aspect of your Sunday worship. Consider this thought-provoking question: If you didn’t have to attend this church because you work here, would you want to? This query isn’t just for paid staff—it’s for everyone involved in making your Sunday services happen, from the greeting team to the worship leaders to the congregants who’ve been attending for decades. Here’s why this question matters:

Contagious Excitement: When your team is genuinely excited about your church and services, it’s palpable. This excitement is contagious, spreading to visitors and regular attendees alike. It creates an atmosphere of anticipation and joy that can transform the worship experience.

 Authentic Engagement: If you and your team are excited to be there, it shows in your interactions, your worship, and your service. People can tell when you’re just going through the motions versus when you’re fully engaged and passionate about what you’re doing. 

Visitor Experience: First-time visitors often decide whether to return based on the overall “vibe” they get from your church. If they sense genuine excitement and engagement from your team and congregation, they’re more likely to want to be part of it. 

Long-term Commitment: For long-time members, maintaining excitement prevents burnout and fosters a deeper connection to the church community. It keeps them engaged and invested in the church’s mission.

If you are not sure you’d want to attend your church if you didn’t have to, then it’s time for some serious reflection. What’s dampening the excitement? Is it the service structure, the content, or perhaps underlying issues in the church culture? Addressing these root causes can revitalize not just your Sunday services, but your entire church. Remember, excitement doesn’t mean you have to have high-energy, charismatic personalities leading everything. Quiet, reverent excitement is just as powerful. The key is that it’s genuine and stems from a deep love for God and His people. Fostering this kind of excitement might involve regularly reminding your team of the “why” behind what you do. Celebrate wins and testimonies of life change. Encourage personal spiritual growth among your leaders and volunteers. Create opportunities for creativity and fresh ideas in your services.

By cultivating an environment of genuine excitement, you create a church that people don’t just attend out of obligation, but one they truly want to be part of—a place where they encounter God and experience authentic community.

Don’t wait to start this evaluation process. After your next Sunday service, gather your team and work through these questions together. Be honest, be open to feedback, and be willing to make changes where necessary. You might be surprised at the insights you gain and the positive changes that result. Ultimately, by consistently asking these questions and acting on the answers, you can create Sunday worship services that not only honor God but also genuinely engage your congregation, reach your community, and further the mission of your church. May God bless you as you lead your congregation in vibrant, transformative worship each and every Sunday.

Watch this episode on YouTube!

Scott Ball is the Vice President and a Lead Guide with The Malphurs Group. He lives in East Tennessee with his wife and two children. (Email Scott).

Got questions? Meet with our team for a free Discovery Call.